title: CS450 layout: true author: Tiago Cogumbreiro lecture: 4 abstract: Recursion, nested definitions sep: &nbsp;☽&nbsp; <img id="logo" src="" height="64" /> .bottom-bar[ {{title}} {{sep}} {{abstract}} {{sep}} Lecture {{lecture}} {{sep}} {{author}} ] --- class: middle # {{title}} ## Structure of Higher Level Languages ### Lecture {{lecture}}: {{abstract}} ### {{author}} --- class: impact # Exercises with lists --- class: full # A template of recursion .col-6[ ### Copying a list ```scheme (define (copy l) (match l [(list) ; input = '() `(list)` ; expected output = '() ] [(cons h l) ; input = (list 1 2 3) ; h = 1 ; l = (list 2 3) (define result (copy l)) ; result = (list 2 3) `(cons h result)` ; expected output = (list 1 2 3) ])) ``` ] .col-6[ ### Notes - `(define (copy l) l)` would be a simpler solution, but we're trying to illustrate a **recursion pattern**. - Remember to write the expected inputs and outputs for a given example - **Part in yellow:** given the expected inputs, how would you build the expected output? ] --- # Lists: example 1 ### Summation of all elements of a list ## Spec ```scheme (require rackunit) (check-equal? 10 (sum-list (list 1 2 3 4))) (check-equal? 0 (sum-list (list))) ``` --- # Lists: example 1 ### Summation of all elements of a list <div class="col-7" markdown> ## Solution ```scheme (define (sum l) (match l [(list) ; input = '() `0`] ; expected output = 0 [(cons h l) ; input = '(1 2 3 4) ; h = 1 ; l = '(2 3 4) ; result = (sum (list 2 3 4)) = 2 + 3 + 4 = 9 (define result (sum l)) `(+ h result)` ])) ; expected output = (+ 1 9) = 10 ``` </div> .col-5[ ## Notes - We use the same pattern as in `copy` - Again, the expression being returned combines `h` and `result` ] --- # Spot the error! (#1) ```scheme #lang racket (define (sum-list l) (match l [empty 0] [(cons h l) (+ h (sum-list l))])) ``` --- # Spot the error! (#1) ```scheme #lang racket (define (sum-list l) (match l [`empty` 0] [(cons h l) (+ h (sum-list l))])) ``` - For `match` consider `empty` to be defined as `(define empty (list))`, not as a keyword - Pattern `empty` means: anything you find assign it to a variable called `empty`; same as writing `[x 0]` - The first branch matches with anything you give it, so this function never recurses --- # Spot the error! (#2) ```scheme #lang racket (define (sum-list l) (match l [(list) 0] [(cons h t) (+ h (sum-list l))])) ``` --- # Spot the error! (#2) ```scheme #lang racket (define (sum-list l) (match l [(list) 0] [(cons h t) (+ h (sum-list `l`))])) ``` - We wanted to recurse on `t`, but instead recursed on the original list `l` - This leads to an **infinite loop** - **Good practice:** use `l` as the rest of the list, and make this error impossible. --- # Spot the error! (#3) ```scheme #lang racket (define (sum-list l) (match l [(list) 0] [(h l) (+ h (sum-list l))])) ``` --- # Spot the error! (#3) ```scheme #lang racket (define (sum-list l) (match l [(list) 0] [(h l) (+ h (sum-list l))])) ``` - We forgot to specify the data-type `cons` in the second pattern - Racket will raise an exception notifying us that the pattern is incorrect ```scheme ex.rkt:5:5: match: syntax error in pattern in: (h l) location...: ex.rkt:5:5 ``` --- # Lists: example 2 ### Returns a list from n down to 1 ## Spec ```scheme (require rackunit) (check-equal? (list) (count-down 0)) (check-equal? (list 3 2 1) (count-down 3)) ``` -- ## Solution ```scheme #lang racket (define (count-down n) (cond [(<= n 0) (list)] [else (cons n (count-down (- n 1)))])) ``` --- # Lists: example 3 ### Point-wise pairing of two lists ## Spec ```scheme (require rackunit) (check-equal? (list (cons 3 30) (cons 2 20) (cons 1 10)) (zip (list 3 2 1) (list 30 20 10))) (check-equal? (list (cons 3 30) (cons 2 20) (cons 1 10)) (zip (list 3 2 1) (list 30 20 10 `5 4 3 2 1`))) (check-equal? (list (cons 3 30) (cons 2 20) (cons 1 10)) (zip (list 3 2 1 `90 180 270`) (list 30 20 10))) ``` --- # Lists: example 3 ### Point-wise pairing of two lists -- ## Solution .col-6[ ```scheme #lang racket (define pair list) ; Encode a pair as a list (define (zip l1 l2) ``` ] -- .row[] .col-6[ ```scheme (match* (l1 l2) [((list) _) (list)] [(_ (list)) (list)] [((cons h1 l1) (cons h2 l2)) (cons (pair h1 h2) (zip l1 l2))])) ``` ] .col-6[ - Use `match*` to pattern match two values at once ] --- class: impact # Using nested definitions --- # Build a list from 1 up to n > Our goal is to build a list from 1 up to some number. > Here is a template of our function and a test case for > us to play with. For the sake of simplicity, we will > not handle non-positive numbers. ```scheme #lang racket (define (countup-from1 x) #f) (require rackunit) (check-equal? (list 1) (countup-from1 1)) (check-equal? (list 1 2) (countup-from1 2)) (check-equal? (list 1 2 3 4 5) (countup-from1 5)) ``` > Hint: write a helper function `count` that builds > counts from `n` up to `m`. --- # Exercise 1: attempt #1 > We write a helper function `count` that builds counts from `n` up to `m`. ```scheme #lang racket (define (countup-from1 x) (count 1 x)) (define (count from to) (cond [(equal? from to) (list to)] [else (cons from (count (+ 1 from) to))])) ``` -- .space-top.center[ ## Let us refactor the code and hide function `count` ] --- # Exercise 1: attempt #2 > We move function `count` to be internal to function `countup-from1`, as it is > a helper function and therefore it is good practice to make it *private* to > `countup-from1`. ```scheme (define (countup-from1 x) ; Internally defined function, not visible from ; the outside * (define (count from to) * (cond [(equal? from to) (list to)] * [else (cons from (count (+ 1 from) to))])) ; The same call as before (count 1 x)) ``` --- # When to nest functions? Nest functions: * If they are unnecessary outside * If they are under development * If you want to hide them: **Every function in the public interface of your code is something you'll have to maintain!** --- class: full, center, middle # Intermission: # Nested definitions --- # Nested definition: local variables > Nested definitions bind a variable within the body of a function and are only visible within that function (these are local variables) ```scheme #lang racket (define (f x) (define z 3) (+ x z)) (+ 1 `z`) ; Error: z is not visible outside function f ``` --- # Nested definitions shadow other variables > Nested definitions silently shadow any already defined variable ```scheme #lang racket (define z 10) (define (f x) (define `x` 3) ; Shadows parameter (define `z` 20) ; Shadows global (+ x z)) (f 1) ; Outputs 23 ``` --- # No redefined local variables > It is an error to re-define local variables ```scheme #lang racket (define (f b) ; OK to shadow a parameter (define b (+ b 1)) (define a 1) ; Not OK to re-define local variables * ; Error: define-values: duplicate binding name (define a (+ a 1)) (+ a b)) ``` --- class: full, center, middle # Back to Exercise 1 --- # Exercise 1: attempt #2 > Notice that we have some redundancy in our code. > .alt[In function `count`, parameter `to` remains unchanged throughout execution.] ```scheme (define (countup-from1 x) ; Internally defined function, not visible from ; the outside (define (count from `to`) (cond [(equal? from to) (list to)] [else (cons from (count (+ 1 from) `to`))])) ; The same call as before (count 1 x)) ``` --- # Exercise 1: attempt #3 > We removed parameter `to` from function `count` as it > was constant throughout the execution. Variable `to` > is captured/copied when `count` is defined. ```scheme (define (countup-from1 to) ; Internally defined function, not visible from ; the outside (define (count from) (cond [(equal? from `to`) (list `to`)] [else (cons from (count (+ 1 from)))])) ; The same call as before (count 1)) ``` --- # Example 1: summary * Use a nested definition to hide a function that is only used internally. * Nested definitions can refer to variables defined outside the scope of their definitions. * The last expression of a function's body is evaluated as the function's return value --- class: impact # Measuring performance --- class: full, center, middle # Example 2 ## Maximum number from a list of integers --- # Example 2: attempt 1 > Finding the maximum element of a list. ```scheme #lang racket (define (max xs) (cond [(empty? xs) (error "max: expecting a non-empty list!")] [(empty? (rest xs)) (first xs)] ; The list only has one element (the max) [(> (first xs) (max (rest xs))) (first xs)] ; The max of the rest is smaller than 1st [else (max (rest xs))])) ; Otherwise, use the max of the rest ; A simple unit-test (require rackunit) (check-equal? 10 (max (list 1 2 10 4 0))) ``` > We use function `error` to abort the program with an exception. --- # Example 2: attempt 1 > Finding the maximum element of a list. Let us benchmark `max` with sorted list (worst-case scenario): * 20 elements: 18.43ms * 21 elements: 36.63ms * 22 elements: 75.78ms > Whenever we add an element we double the execution time. .alt[Why?] --- # Example 2: attempt 1 > Whenever we hit the else branch (because we can't find the maximum), > we re-compute the max element. ```scheme (define (max xs) (cond [(empty? xs) (error "max: expecting a non-empty list!")] [(empty? (rest xs)) (first xs)] ; The list only has one element (the max) [(> (first xs) `(max (rest xs))`) (first xs)] ; The max of the rest is smaller than 1st [else `(max (rest xs))`])) ; Otherwise, use the max of the rest ``` --- # Example 2: attempt 2 > We use a local variable to cache a duplicate computation. ```scheme (define (max xs) (cond [(empty? xs) (error "max: expecting a non-empty list!")] [(empty? (rest xs)) (first xs)] [else * (define rest-max (max (rest xs))) ; Cache the max of the rest * (cond * [(> (first xs) rest-max) (first xs)] * [else rest-max])])) ``` * Attempt #1: 20 elements in 75.78ms * Attempt #2: 1,000,000 elements in 101.15ms --- # Example 2 takeaways * Use nested definitions to cache intermediate results * Identify repeated computations and cache them in nested (local) definitions